Secrecy Kills Trust

by Kim Staudenraus on August 4, 2010

Our blog is titled  life and finances, the reason being is the fact that finances or money touches just about every aspect of our life.  It is very difficult to separate the two because sooner or later the two topics intersect.

A recurring theme that I continue to see in the lives of couples is secrecy about spending money as well as about how much money is being made and or saved.  Sadly, I have also found that if someone is being secretive about money, chances are they are being secretive about other things as well.

Relationships are built on trust.  Without trust it is near impossible to have a true intimate relationship.  This holds true with any relationship but especially between husband and wife.  If one person in the relationship is continually being secretive, about anything, the other person starts to lose trust.  Trust is built on openness and honesty, once it is violated, and many times continually violated it is near impossible to rebuild trust to the level that it was prior to the violation.

Now let me be clear here, I am not talking about secrets like a surprise party or surprise vacation somewhere, I am talking about a consistent behavior of intentional secrecy and that is the bases of this post.

Some people are secretive because they have had their trust violated at some point in their past, we all know that we carry some sort of baggage into relationships.  The key is to take that baggage and open it all up to your spouse so old hurts and trust violations don’t infect your current relationship.  Yes, there is a risk you will be hurt and trust may be violated again by doing so, but by not doing so, they hurt will fester anyway.

Secrecy in couples about money is rampant.  Many times one spouse who handles the bills and the other has no idea what is going on with the money.  In most cases, not all, but most, one spouse knows the other spouse is doing something “funny” with the money but out of fear they do not ask questions or get involved because they are afraid they may lose what they have….this is no way to live in a relationship if you can even call it a relationship.

Let me preface that this isn’t about a healthy couple where one spouse is handling the bills because they are good at it and they do keep the other spouse in the loop of the financial situation of the household, this is about a spouse who intentionally handles the bills to keep the other spouse in the dark of the financial situation.

Secrecy occurs because one spouse is doing something they KNOW is wrong.  Let me repeat, secrecy occurs because one spouse is doing something they know is wrong, they know their partner would not approve.  It may be a bit on the illegal side either in mans law, God’s law…or both.  Actually secrecy is already against God’s law because it is a form of deception, check out the ninth commandment.

There is no good that can come out of secrecy especially when it comes to money (there is no good from any secret behavior in a relationship baring the above disclaimer about a surprise party of something of that sort) but especially when it comes to money.  The person keeping the financial secrets will be found out, sooner or later, and it will hurt the person who has been in the dark.

There was a couple who came to me for money management coaching.  The husband had no clue about the concept of money much less how to manage it.  He took charge of all the bills and for good reason he was keeping his wife in the dark about what was going on.  The way she found out there was a problem was when a sheriff knocked on their door and presented her with a summons to appear in court.  She was being sued by a credit card company for not paying the bill.  A bill that she knew nothing about, a credit card she did NOT open.  Her husband opened a credit card under her name.  He sat across from me and said with a  straight face that he did nothing wrong.  That they were married, and as a married couple they shared everything, he shared her good credit and now she shared his bad credit due to his secret of opening a credit card under his wife’s name.

Folks, regardless of marital status, he broke the law.  He committed fraud by forging her name and her signature to obtain the credit card in her name without her knowledge or permission.  It is called identity theft even if you are stealing it from your one flesh spouse.  Actually most common instances of identity theft is with someone you know or are related to.  Regardless of reasons for doing so, it was a dishonest act, as well as secretive.  His wife found out in the long run from the Sheriff.   In this case she did not file criminal charges nor did the credit card company because the wife agreed to pay the bill.  Sadly, not more than a year later the same thing happened again, the second time she did file charges…a relationship failed in divorce due to secrecy and deceit.

Yes, deceit goes hand in hand with secrecy.  Some think they are not lying if they don’t actually speak the lie, however, there is such a thing as lying by omission.  Secrecy is a form of deception and we all know deception is lying.  It goes back to, if you  are not doing anything wrong, what would be the purpose in being secretive to your spouse?

The reason I am sharing this is to encourage you to be open and honest about your finances to your spouse.   If you can’t, take a good hard look at why you can’t be open and honest.  Why are you being secretive?  Yes, I have heard all the excuses like “well my spouse wouldn’t understand” or “I don’t want to be nagged about my spending habits” or “I make the money, there is no reason for my spouse to know what I am doing with it as long as the bills are being paid.”  The list of excuses I hear goes on and on but you get the jest.  Bottom line ladies and gentlemen if you want your marriage to be successful your must be open and honest with each other.  Yes, there will be times when you will make a mistake.  There will be times when your spouse may get onto you or “nag” you about the financial situation, but the pain of that moment is far less severe  than when the secret comes out in the open and potentially causes a divorce and believe me, the secret ALWAYS comes out sooner or later.

Secrecy destroys trust, when trust is broken, the relationship will struggle from there on out and that environment isn’t good for either party.  Re-exam your life and your actions.  Look at your character, do you represent Christ to your spouse?  If you are ashamed of your actions, which you must be if you are being secretive, why not turn over a new leaf and open yourself up with honesty toward your spouse?  You will be amazed how much smoother your life will flow, as well as how much calmer and more at peace you will feel.

There are some who are secretive because you don’t know how to communicate with your spouse.  Communication and listening take practice to get some help with communication I highly recommend the book  Love & Respect: The Love She Most Desires; The Respect He Desperately Needs

by Dr. Emerson Eggrichs.  This book will help both husband and wife better understand each other.  If you understand each other you can then better share and communicate what you are doing, there will be no need to keeping a secret because you will know how the other person will respond.  It will help teach you how to live in a relationship the way Christ intended.  It is not focused on money, but it is focused on doing what is right in a marriage with your spouse.

Another fantastic resources is an eBook that has sold over 61,000 copies.  The title is “Save Your Christian Marriage” but that is not to say this book is only for those who are on the path to divorce.  The lessons taught will strengthen marriage regardless of the current state it is in.  It is more than just an eBook, it is a lesson plan on how to be married.  Face it nobody knows how, that is evident by the secrecy in marriages today as well as the divorce rate, this book shares and teaches you how to be a better for yourself so you can be better for your spouse.  If you don’t do anything else that I have mentioned here today, please do this one thing, get this eBook, it will change your marriage, it will eliminate the secrecy and build up trust again.  It will save your marriage, from what you learn in this book you can apply these principles how to live better financially, why?  Because the two of you will now be on the same page together, openly and honestly.

If you want your life to continue on as it is, do nothing else, actually if that is the case chances are you haven’t even read down this far.  But, if you are ready to improve who you are, improve your marriage, save your marriage even if you are not the one being secretive, get the “Save Your Christian Marriage” book today by click here now.  You won’t regret it one bit.  Then after you are done reading the book, and putting some of the lessons into practice, which will be very easy I might add, come back here and comment on this post, share with others how your marriage has improved with openness and honesty.

We are proud to have this article featured on:
One Family's Blog
Gather Little by Little
Jevlir Caravansary

{ 0 comments }

Living Beyond Our Means

by Kim Staudenraus on August 2, 2010

Dear WWKD,

My husband and I have an investment condo. We have been able
to rent the unit for the last 5 years however we were never able to rent
it for the full amount of the mortgage plus HOA dues.  We owe approximately 30k more than it is worth.  Although it is an inconvenience to rent it, and we
lose approximately $260 every month I don’t want to foreclose and
have that on my credit rating.  However, my husband thinks it is best to
foreclose.  Need some guidance!!  What would you do?  BTW  we are living approximately $250.00 dollars beyond our monthly budget at this time.

What would Kim do?  Signed: Beyond our Budget

Dear Beyond our Budget,

An investment condo means that you are in a positive cash flow each month or that your plan shows there will be a positive cash flow in the very near future.  In your case I don’t see either.  If you have been losing $260 each month for the last 5 year that means you have lost $15,600 over the last five years on something you purchased with the intent to provide additional income.

If you are like most people, you are not in a position to consistently lose money, in fact you made that point clear by stating you are living $250 beyond your monthly budget each month.

Here a question, is that  $250 because of the $260/mo loss from the condo or is it in addition to that meaning you are at a $510 deficit each month?

What I would do is sell the condo, even at a $30k loss.  Get a loan for the difference and pay it off.  Yep, that hurts, but there is no better learning experience than one that hits your wallet.  I am not a big fan of foreclosure unless there are NO alternatives, I don’t see that as being the case here.  If that isn’t an option, you could always increase the rent, but I suspect in this market, there are plenty of condos available for rent so most likely your renter would just move on leaving you in the whole for the full amount each month.  Best to sell at a loss.  Be sure to properly inform your renters of your intent…no reason why they should suffer due to your financial issues.

Regarding living beyond your budget each month by $250, I would revisit my budget.  Time to cut back on something, cable TV, eating out, maybe even selling a car that has payments.  There is no way I would live in the beyond my budget each month, that means you are not living on your own, you are charging your living habits somewhere.  There is some behavior that must changed or something maybe multiple things need to be sold.

{ 0 comments }

Owning a home – a dream or a nightmare?

August 1, 2010

It’s the American dream to own a home.   However, sometimes that dream turns into a nightmare. A home is a wonderful thing, it means privacy, independence, to some it means success and status symbol.   But a home is much more than all these things, it is a huge financial commitment and I don’t just mean [...]

Read the full article →

Income from Rental Doesn’t Pay the Mortgage

July 30, 2010

WWKD, I have two properties.  One I live in the other I rent at negative cash flow of $200. I owe $103,000 market value $67,000. property is 26 year old. Should I foreclose and get read of it? Should I stop payment on it? How bad will that affect my credit score although it may [...]

Read the full article →

Choosing Bankruptcy

July 30, 2010

Yes, you read the title right.  I am actually writing a post about choosing bankruptcy.  No, I haven’t changed my mind about bankruptcy, it is still not something I recommend.  However, I realize that many of you struggling with debt feel it is your only choice. So since  bankruptcy may be the option you choose [...]

Read the full article →

More Month than Money

July 29, 2010

WWKD, So Kim, if I come up short $500.00 each month on my quickie budget…and I have a small draw that does not cover my bills AND I will not sell my house in this down economy and lose my equity situation what do you suggest?  I would like someone to look at my budget [...]

Read the full article →

File for Bankruptcy?

July 1, 2010

WWKD, We have 36k in credit card debt.  We make around $6,400 a month after taxes.  The mortgage payment is $1,500 and we are current.  We are able to pay  utilities and food as well as the car payments but that is about it.  The credit card companies are bugging us everyday wanting money from [...]

Read the full article →

It’s About Behavior & Income

June 30, 2010

When coaching clients I have always focused on the fact that being in debt is not so much about money but more about behavior.   That it is about 80% behavior and 20% income. I realized that I was so focused in helping each of you look at your spending behavior as well as how to [...]

Read the full article →

Should we Walk away from our home?

June 27, 2010

WWKD, We currently have a first mortgage of $280,000 with an interest only adjustable rate of 5.5% that will begin to adjust in January. We also have a second mortgage of $140,000 with an interest only rate of prime minus 1/2 that will be due in full sometime in 12 years. We tried to refinance [...]

Read the full article →

Pay Tithe or Bills?

June 27, 2010

WWKD, Money is very tight, we make it each much but barely. We know we are suppose to pay tithe but don’t see in the number how that is possible. How do we pay tithe when at the end of the month there is no money left after we pay all the bills and buy [...]

Read the full article →